Jesus Montero
Mariners split with Pirates in defacto doubleheader
The new alignment structure in Major League Baseball, where interleague games are played on nearly every day of the season, was bound to cause some scheduling oddities. This week marked the first time the Mariners felt the strain of those changes.
Seattle split with the NL Central’s Pittsburgh Pirates in a pair of games played at 4:07 pm PT Tuesday evening and 9:35 am PT Wednesday morning. Besides the fact the players likely slept last night, they essentially played a doubleheader in between days off Monday and Thursday. While the games proved an odd sandwich of battles, here’s a few things the Mariners taught the casual observer over the course of less than 24 hours.
The Mariners aren’t built to win in the National League
The nine-hole is already a throwaway spot in the order for the team with Robert Andino/Brendan Ryan combining for around .150. Add in the pitcher spot instead of a useful designated hitter position, and that’s two throwaways. Unsurprisingly, the only time these spots produced hits in the series was when Raul Ibanez had an RBI double in game one while pinch hitting. Also unsurprisingly, the Mariners only put up three runs on eight hits in the two games.
The King stay the King
Shoutout to “The Wire” for that one, but Felix Hernandez truly pitched his rear end off today. He battled back from surrendering a first-inning run to allow just four hits over his final seven innings of work. A spectacular Felix was the only way the Mariners were coming out of Pittsburgh with a win, and he delivered, improving to 5-2 with a 1.53 ERA on the year. The game marked Felix’s fourth consecutive victory.
Montero shines when Felix pitches
The 2013 season has not treated Jesus Montero nicely, but he has shined in spots. In today’s win, he made two huge plays to win the game for the Mariners. First, he hit the game-winning home run in the seventh inning off of A.J. Burnett, who pitched extremely well in defeat. Montero also picked off Startling Marte in a huge spot to end the eighth inning. It was perhaps his best performance of the season, with the possible exception of April 28′s 3-2 win over the Angels, when Montero hit a big tying home run in the sixth inning. The pitcher that day? Felix Hernandez. The Mariners are 3-0 this season when Montero homers.
The Mariners are off Thursday before Hisashi Iwakuma takes the mound Friday night at Safeco against Oakland.
Tags: 2013 Season, featured, Felix Hernandez, Jesus Montero, Popular, Recaps, seattle mariners, Series Recaps
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
The Case for Demoting Jesus Montero
You know those “Jesus is _____” bumper stickers? Every time I see one of those, I want to walk up with a pen and write “only hitting .203″ on the blank line. Sure, the vehicle’s owner might not get nor appreciate the joke, but hey, don’t buy a fill-in-the-blank bumper sticker next time.
In fact, you could make all sorts of “Jesus is” wisecracks when it comes to Mariners catcher Jesus Montero. Jesus is 0-for-15 in throwing out stealing base runners. Jesus is unable to hit a curveball. Or how about this one: Jesus is destined for Triple-A. It’s that last “Jesus is” that might be most concerning. But based on current circumstances, it should become the team’s reality.
Montero has been abysmal both offensively and defensively in 2013. He hasn’t hit for average or for power, and he hasn’t even been close to adequate behind the plate. As alluded to earlier, Montero has yet to nab a base-stealer in 15 tries and has often looked stiff and uncomfortable receiving pitches. Were he hitting .300 with a handful of home runs, no one would care that the 23-year-old was providing less-than-serviceable defense. But as the owner of a .203/.250/.324 slash line, Montero certainly isn’t atoning for his shortcomings in the field right now.
Recently, it’s been rumored that manager Eric Wedge has been pressured from the organization’s front office to play Montero on a more frequent basis. Montero has received (note: not earned) a slight bump in playing time, taking about two-thirds of the starts to backup Kelly Shoppach’s one-third. Even with increased opportunity, however, the second-year big leaguer has yet to deliver. In his past 10 games, the ex-Yankee is performing no more remarkably than he was at the season’s outset, compiling a .194 batting average along the way (though, in fairness, he has belted his only two home runs of the year in that span). Nevertheless, settling in around the Mendoza Line does not a major leaguer make. Montero doesn’t necessarily have to hit for both average AND power (it’d be nice, though), but he can’t get by with a sub-.200 line.
Aside from his hitting struggles, where player and team have most failed to align is in their commitment to one another. The franchise seems committed to giving Montero a long look at catcher. Montero, meanwhile, seems committed to proving he is not that at all. Rock, meet hard place. The end result of this mutual stubbornness is a big ol’ crap sandwich. It doesn’t have to be that way.
Everyone and their mother knows that the M’s catcher of the future currently resides at Triple-A Tacoma. The uber-prospect that is Mike Zunino has had an up and down start to his 2013 campaign. This isn’t unanticipated. Zunino has yet to play a full season in the pros, and were all to go according to plan, he wouldn’t see his first action at Safeco Field until 2014. Problem is, Montero’s struggles have accelerated the demand for a Zunino call-up.
Zunino and Montero are mutually exclusive entities. No one should believe a demotion of Montero will necessarily result in a promotion of Zunino. Montero has done nothing to earn his spot on the big league roster, however, and shouldn’t be here anymore. Not if this team is truly committed to winning.
It’s clear that if the Mariners really want Montero to experience life behind the plate, he should be playing every single day. It’s also clear that, based on the way he’s been playing, Montero has done very little to warrant an everyday spot in the lineup. Therefore, all signs point to sending Montero to the minors, giving the majority of the big league starts (for now) to Kelly Shoppach, and promoting anyone else with a pulse not named Zunino to be Shoppach’s understudy. In this case, that might be Triple-A backup Jesus Sucre, who is nothing special with the bat, but can actually live up to his job title and, you know, catch.
Of course, this begs the question of what to do with Zunino in the interim. If Montero and Zunino share a clubhouse, only one can log time behind the plate. Fact is, the Mariners need to make a hard call on their catchers. Could they teach Montero how to play first base? Maybe. Could they let both players work on their hitting while splitting time as backstops? Possibly. Could they send Montero to Double-A to work on his receiving skills? That’s also an option. Honestly, it really doesn’t matter what the organization does so long as they jettison Montero to the farm and prove to both players and fans that they a) want to give opportunities to the most deserving players, and b) believe the 2013 Mariners aren’t losers. Seriously. Because, to date, the current regime has never shown much in the way of faith for their ballclub, regardless of how many wins the team can string together at any given moment. It’s about time they display some commitment to a winning mentality, and that starts by demoting those who deserve to be demoted.
Jesus is not for long in the big leagues. It’s time the Mariners filled in the blank.
Filed under: Mariners
Tags: Jesus Montero, Jesus Sucre, Kelly Shoppach, Mike Zunino, Tacoma Rainiers
Posted in: Mariners, Uncategorized | No Comments »
SSN Twitterbag: Antoine Winfield’s future, Mariner busts, the limit on what we’ll let fall in our beer, and more
It’s like a mailbag, but with Twitter. Because outside of work, no one sends emails anymore. To participate in future Twitterbags, look for the #SSNTwitterbag hashtag and follow along, @alexSSN.
Will Antoine Winfield sign [with the Seahawks]? -via @caseyc8
Winfield, a 35-year-old free agent cornerback just released by Minnesota, is one of the premier players at his position, even at this late stage in his career. A former All-Pro and three-time Pro Bowl honoree, Winfield reportedly worked out with the Seahawks just a few days ago.
To atone for my relative ignorance on Winfield’s contractual prospects, I went to one of the brightest football minds I know for some help. My buddy Curtis Crabtree (speaking of Twitter, follow him @Curtis_Crabtree) — who covers the Seahawks for Sports Radio KJR, as well as the west coast for ProFootballTalk — was able to provide some insight for us on the situation:
“Winfield would fill a big need for Seattle as a slot cornerback,” said Curtis. “Seattle has more cap space available than Minnesota and his release from the Vikings wasn’t particularly amicable. Minnesota is pushing hard to keep him, but the manner of his release may push him to head to the Seahawks.”
Winfield was released by the Vikings on March 12, a move made in large part to clear cap space. His termination was brought to his attention while he was working out at the team’s facility, hence the less-than-amicable separation.
With more money to offer and the potential of a Super Bowl season ahead, it certainly appears like the Seahawks may have the inside track on Winfield right now.
Is it still too early to call [Dustin] Ackley and/or [Jesus] Montero a bust? -via @AndyTheG
Yes. Without a doubt, yes.
Sure, both Ackley and Montero have struggled for the bulk of their tenures in Seattle, and have especially struggled of late. While each were deemed top prospects, both have been seemingly cursed by the expectations that come along with such lofty praise.
Though there’s still time for both Ackley and Montero to develop, perhaps most concerning is the fact that neither player has shown much in the way of improvement over much of the past year. Ackley has showcased a revamped batting stance that looks about as comfortable as a pair of skinny jeans, while Montero’s weight transfer has been atrocious, sending him flailing out in front of pitches before they’re halfway to home plate.
Ackley will be granted plenty of time to work out his issues, with seemingly no other options at second base. (Unless the team wants to shift Kyle Seager over there and see what they have in a third base prospect, such as Nick Franklin; unlikely at this point.) Montero, on the other hand, is under the gun with 2012 first-round draft pick Mike Zunino off to a blazing start at Triple-A Tacoma. Fans are already eager for Zunino’s arrival, and if the organization is forced to promote him out of merit, it will likely be Montero that either finds his way to the minors or suffers from limited playing time.
Another factor in all this is Justin Smoak, who may be closer to “bust” status than either of his younger counterparts. Smoak is hanging by a final thread with the M’s, and if he can’t reveal any promise over the first few weeks of the season, his days in a Mariners uniform are undoubtedly numbered. Smoak and Montero are inextricably tied to one another in that each can lay claim to a finite number of at-bats in the lineup. Should Zunino arrive in Seattle and remain entrenched behind the plate, as expected, the team will need to find an alternate plan for Montero. Were he to shift to designated hitter, that would push Kendrys Morales over to first base, eliminating Smoak’s role with the ballclub. Longer term, the M’s may have plans to utilize Montero as a first baseman, since that is really the only other position on the field he could capably play.
Either way, one fact remains: Zunino’s arrival in Seattle will dramatically alter the roles of either Montero or Smoak, and possibly both. And it’s not so much “if” Zunino arrives as it is “when.” Between Montero and Smoak, will a bust emerge in due time? Probably so.
How much are you going to miss Abdul Gaddy running the point next year? -via @AZinSeattle
About as much as I miss Ed Hardy shirts, episodes of Gilmore Girls, awkward middle school slow dances, and Chone Figgins, combined. Good riddance.
What will our NHL team be called? Thunderbirds, or something new and fierce like Seattle Frozen Rain Droplets? -via @waltswarriors
First of all, nicknames that invoke nature or acts of nature are usually reserved for WNBA teams. The Sun, the Storm, the Sky, the list goes on. That said, a fiercer act of nature like Frozen Rain Droplets may have potential. Perhaps something even more geographically relevant — like Seattle Icy Pavement, or Seattle Drive Slow In The Rain — might be worth considering.
In reality, the favorites in the clubhouse so far seem to be Thunderbirds and Metropolitans, with Metropolitans getting the early nod. The Metropolitans reference is a tip of the cap to days gone by — the Seattle Mets were the first Stanley Cup Champions, after all — while the Thunderbirds are of course most pertinent to today’s generation of local hockey fans. Personally, I’m not really biased towards either nickname, which may mean we need something new altogether. Perhaps a naming contest is in order…
How good will Husky hoops in general be next year? Nationally ranked? Tourney bound at least? -via @AndersJorstad
Over the span of a few weeks, the Huskies have gone about revamping their roster in a curious fashion, putting themselves in the conversation for a return to Pac-12 relevance in 2013-2014.
Back in March, the Huskies landed a verbal commitment from JUCO swingman Mike Anderson, a 6-5 guard-forward who averaged 16.9 points and 9.8 rebounds at Moberly Area Community College this past season. Though not a big name, Anderson’s résumé immediately invoked memories of another former junior college transfer from days gone by, Tre Simmons.
In addition to Anderson, it’s been rumored in recent days that UNLV forward Mike Moser will be playing his senior season on Montlake as a graduate transfer, meaning he’s eligible to contribute immediately and will not need to redshirt. Moser is finishing up his undergraduate studies this year and because of a prior redshirt season taken when he migrated from UCLA to Las Vegas, still maintains a year of NCAA eligibility. Though he’d only play one year with the Huskies, the 6-8 Moser would undoubtedly be a major contributor if healthy. Coming out of high school in the Portland area, Moser was heavily recruited by a number of teams across the nation, including Washington. Though Lorenzo Romar ultimately missed out on Moser, he may have a chance to secure the ex-Rebel for his collegiate swan song. You can read more about the impending transfer here.
With another senior, 6-9 power forward Perris Blackwell, set to make his Washington debut in 2013, the Huskies suddenly become an intriguing blend of young and old. Should C.J. Wilcox forgo the temptations of the NBA and return for his senior campaign, the Dawgs will boast a trio of fifth-year players who could lead them back to the NCAA Tournament for the first time in three seasons.
Beyond the aforementioned additions, Washington brings in a freshman recruiting class led by McDonald’s All-American Nigel Williams-Goss, a 6-3 point guard from Happy Valley, Oregon. Darin Johnson, a 6-4 shooting guard from Sacramento, and Jahmel Taylor, a 5-11 point guard from Los Angeles, round out the crop of first-year players. Williams-Goss, especially, should have an instant impact, offloading some of the playmaking duties from returning redshirt sophomore Andrew Andrews, and likely assuming a fair share of the scoring duties, as well.
It will be interesting to see how the new players blend with the returning roster. With a marked improvement in talent, at least on paper, it will be up to Coach Romar and staff to mold personalities and ensure a comfortable working environment for all involved. Should this team play up to its potential, and more importantly play together, a return to the Big Dance and national relevance isn’t out of the question at all.
You seemed so confident about the Sonics next season. Are you still? -via @bryanwhite05
For months, I’ve operated under the assumption that the Sonics will be playing in Seattle in 2013. All of Kevin Johnson’s pomp and circumstance, all of the NBA’s rhetoric, and all the back-and-forth between the Maloofs and the city of Sacramento can’t change my opinion: I’m convinced the Kings are destined to become Seattle’s team before year’s end.
Sure, I’ve followed the saga on sports radio, in the news, on Twitter, etc., but I’m not letting the roller coaster ride sway me. I’d rather stay positive, trust the businessmen (and the lawyers) involved, and look towards that light at the end of the tunnel. I’m absolutely confident.
Regardless of how you may feel, however, we should have a better idea of where things are headed within the next eight days. Assuming everything goes according to schedule, we’ll know by April 20 whether we will or will not have an NBA team in the Emerald City next season.
Will Saved By the Bell ever do any 20- or 30-year high school reunion specials? -via @HuskyThor
This is one of those things that’s near and dear to my heart. Saved By the Bell is without a doubt one of my favorite sitcoms of all-time, and in recent years the people behind the show have gone about teasing us with the prospect of a reunion special on more than one occasion. Problem is, there are two holdups: Lisa and Screech, or more accurately, the real-life actors who play them, Lark Voorhies and Dustin Diamond.
Voorhies has battled her own personal demons, a battle that has been documented in the press over the past year or so. It’s rumored that she may be bipolar and, as a result, has all but given up acting while she sorts out her personal life.
Diamond is the cast’s pariah, an abrasive figure who has fallen out with just about all of his former Bell-mates. Whether or not he’d be on board for a reunion wouldn’t so much be determined by his own desires as it would by his standing with those he’d be working with. If Screech can’t get along with everyone else, a reunion project probably can’t be green-lit. While spinoffs of the original show have done okay without Lisa’s character (Lisa did not appear in recurring fashion during The College Years), the role of Screech has graced every SBTB-related project to date.
It’s been two decades since Bayside High School’s most famous class received their diplomas. A 20-year reunion would be well-received by an entire generation that still watches SBTB reruns to this day. For now, though, we continue to wait.
What is the limit to what you would let fall in a beer while still chugging it? Given that a sports beer is ~$8, when is enough, enough? We saw [the beer catch] but what about an earpiece, etc? -via @johng365
First of all, if you haven’t seen Wednesday night’s beer catch, go, now. It’s pretty amazing. Definitely worth a few seconds of your time. Catching a baseball in one’s plastic pint cup has got to be a bucket list item for any self-respecting, beer-drinking baseball fan. Would any of us not be willing to sacrifice a cold one for a souvenir as coveted as a foul ball? I like to think we’d all give up our beers for that.
This raises that all-important question, however: Where is that line on stadium beer sacrifice? A debate for the ages, without a doubt.
For me, personally, the cost of a stadium beer pales in comparison to a moment of infamy. Catching just about anything worth YouTubing in my drink would be valuable. But I’m a media whore, so naturally a bit biased. And this all assumes that a camera is in place to capture the moment of (glory?) glory. For instance, if someone chucked an earpiece into my Coors Light and it wasn’t recorded, then I’d just be some poor sap who wasted $8 or $9 on a now-tainted beer. The thought of guzzling a drink that may contain a fair amount of ear wax turns my stomach, so that beer is bound for the garbage either way. I can happily live with it, though, if I’ve found my way to the pages of Deadspin as a result.
If we operate under the hypothetical of a camera-free world, the list of things I’d let fall into my beer dramatically shortens. A baseball is still a definite yes, and likely rises to the top of the list when it comes to exciting beer finds. Anyone who’s ever taken a baseball home from the ballpark understands the excitement associated with that moment. Including me:
After the prospect of a foul ball gracing your beverage, the awesome sports-related paraphernalia you could drop into an already-full pint glass are few and far between. A hockey puck? Totally cool. A golf ball? Absolutely. A tennis ball? Sure. But then what?
A player’s mouthpiece? Eh, probably not worth it.
A batting glove? Maybe.
A wad of Bazooka chewed by your favorite player? Some might go for it, but not me.
A shooting sleeve? No.
Really, outside of a baseball, there aren’t many coveted stadium items that would warrant losing a beer over. If you want to open the book up to include the likes of a World Series ring or a $100 bill then yes, we can absolutely talk about ditching that ale you’ve been chugging. Beyond that? Well, let’s just be thankful for cameras and the world of social media. Because really, those fleeting seconds of fame and relevance are all that make an $8 waste of money okay.
Thanks to everyone for contributing their questions to this edition of the Twitterbag. Stay tuned via Twitter for our next Twitterbag request.
Filed under: Twitterbag
Tags: Antoine Winfield, Beer Catch, dustin ackley, Husky Basketball, Jesus Montero, Sonics, Twitterbag
Posted in: Mariners, Uncategorized | No Comments »
(Maybe) This is The Year
In between Sunday afternoons spent watching Nickelodeon Guts and Family Double Dare and all the other kid shows that permeated every kid’s existence in the kid-friendly, kid-centric Nineties, I was a baseball fan. My summers were punctuated by bruises and scuffed knees and mosquito bites that only seemed to multiply each time I scratched them. I had a glove with Ken Griffey Jr.’s name burned into the pocket, a wardrobe full of blue and yellow Mariners apparel, snapback caps with an “S” on the crown, and this belief, however foolish, that I would one day grow up to be them.
Throughout the duration of every season, I would type up, print out, and maintain a list of each player on the Mariners’ active roster. Jersey number, name, and position. If Dann Howitt got called up from Triple-A, then by god you’d find me in front of a Macintosh Classic typing Howitt’s information into Microsoft Works. And if I went to a game to discover that Howitt’s jersey number had inexplicably been switched from 23 to 44, upon arriving home that edit would be made, saved, printed, and kept. I could give you the details on every single player, from No. 1 (Greg Briley and Brian Turang) all the way to No. 96 (Mak Suzuki).
Fashion conscious as I was, my mother let me dress myself from an early age. So unlike many of my elementary school peers, adorned in expensive button-ups from Nordstrom and pants that didn’t have an elastic waistband, I was as comfortable and content as any child could possibly be — in third grade, for example, I wore shorts for an entire school year, just because. Mostly, though, I attired myself in t-shirts with cartoon images of Junior on the front, “life-size” jersey replicas of Randy Johnson, and colorful advertisements for the American League Western Division. I wore those shirts down to their last threads. I sweat and fought and bled and cried in those shirts. I had unforgettable experiences in those shirts. I lived an entire adolescence with sweatshirts tied around my waist, securing those shirts through recess after recess as we tossed Nerf Vortex Screamers, held footraces, shot baskets, kicked red rubber spheres, and chased our imaginations across wood chips and dirt fields.
I sat on metal benches — some with red backs, some with orange — and devoured nachos, peanuts, hot dogs, Milk Duds, and any other stadium fare one could conceivably dream up. I blew bubbles of Green Apple Bubblicious gum, then stuffed the popped remains into my lower lip to look like the ballplayers with their chewing tobacco, the ones whose bad habits I couldn’t help but emulate. I stood in the Kingdome concourse and marveled at the souvenir stands, staring down brand new caps, jerseys, jackets, pennants, trading card sets, pins, replica helmets, mini bats, photo balls, blow up bones, everything. Who didn’t want a gold No. 24 necklace? So what if it was $10? It was $10 well spent.
There was no cynicism in those days. We were bad, but we were a dignified sort of bad. We had never won, so there was no expectation to win. Our guys, they just played baseball. And when they won, we were happy. And when they lost, we moved on. We watched players come and go, the ones who wanted to be here staying until those star-crossed seasons when we actually began to win. They led us proudly into a world of expectation. When they left, when we lost again, our innocence was replaced by that cynicism, by a bit of newfound impatience that couldn’t be satiated until we won again. We won again. And even those players left. We lost again. We haven’t won since.
Every spring we find ourselves in this position. The days get longer, the sun shines brighter, and we start believing that maybe, just maybe, this will be the year. So what if we were downright mediocre last season? So what if our competition improved? Do you see that sunshine? Do you feel that warmth? It’s almost summertime! If the clouds can dissipate and the rain can cease and the sun can shine here, now…well, anything must be possible. We are easily swayed, us Mariner fans. Or maybe we’re just blessed with bigger hearts, bigger imaginations, and smaller whatever-it-is that makes you think clearly even in the face of sheer obviousness.
There’s a chance. We get to play the Astros 19 times this year. Nineteen! And the Astros might not even win a game. Really, they’re that bad.
We have a middle-of-the-order now: Kendrys Morales, Mike Morse, Jesus Montero. We have hitters that actually scare pitchers — or if not scare them, perhaps make their blood pressure rise just a tad.
We have an ace, a King, and he’s not going anywhere for a long time. Players want to play with him, for him. They certainly don’t want to go against him. He’s our fulcrum. Everyone knows it, and everyone respects it.
We have pitchers who can pitch, hitters who can hit, fielders who can field, we got real jerseys and everything! Okay, so maybe that’s oversimplifying things a bit. But we’re not bad. We’re at least okay. And okay sometimes has a way of spiraling its way into good, which can sometimes spiral its way into great. And from there, who knows.
Mostly, though, we have players who won’t make a mockery of our memories. We have guys who want to wear a Mariners uniform. Guys like Felix Hernandez, who cried tears of joy when he inked a contract that will keep him here for the better part of the next decade. Guys like the aforementioned Morse, who was ecstatic upon learning he had been traded to the first organization that ever let him play in the big leagues. Guys like Raul Ibanez, who signed on to finish his career in Seattle just because he likes it here. Every time we’ve ever won, we’ve had players who truly wanted to be in Seattle. Players that made you like them, if for no other reason than the fact that they seemed to understand, in some way or another, that you as a child had worn the same logo they now wore, had scraped your knees in that logo the way they scraped theirs, had sweat in that logo just as they now sweat.
We don’t ask for much in Seattle. We’re an enigma to sports fans outside our corner of the map. We don’t demand winners so much as we beg for them. We don’t expect success so much as we bask in its aura. At the end of the day, all we really ask for is new memories to be made and old memories to be enhanced. Winning, as it turns out, has a way of fulfilling both those requests.
The Seattle Mariners are dealing with a generation of fans who grew up wearing the colors and the emblem of a team that sucked, but sucked in a beautifully organic, pure, simple way. Our innocence mirrored the innocence of an entire organization. We grew up together, and as we’ve grown up, our experiences have shaped the way we approach the future in tandem with one another. We can be cynical at times, we can be unsatisfied quite frequently, we can be down on our prospects, upset with our situation.
But every spring, right about this time of year, all of that is replaced by unbridled optimism. We see the good in one another — us in them, them in us — and we believe that this might just possibly be the year. Maybe. Maybe this is the year.
Filed under: Mariners
Tags: Felix Hernandez, Jesus Montero, mike morse, Raul Ibanez
Posted in: Mariners, Uncategorized | No Comments »
Spring Training 2013: The Catchers on the Roster
Everyone has reported, and the spring training games have begun. it’s time to take an early look at how the different members of the roster and the invitees are doing thus far. Already on the roster are Jesus Montero and Kelly Shoppach, and John Hicks, Ronny Paulino, Jesus Sucre, and Mike Zunino are non-roster invitees hopeful to demonstrate to the coaches just what they are made of. For now, let’s look at the catchers who are on the Mariners’ roster.

February 22, 2013; Peoria, AZ, USA; Seattle Mariners catcher Jesus Montero (63) throws the baseball to the pitcher between pitches during the third inning against the San Diego Padres at Peoria Sports Complex. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports
#63 Jesus Montero
Despite the bit of bad press Montero has received in recent weeks, he’s been preforming well at spring camp. He maintains that neither he nor his brother (also Jesus Montero) who plays for the Cardinals have never been associated with the Biogenesis clinic. When it came to commenting on the accusations, Montero had the following to say:
“I don’t really know what’s going on,” Montero said. “I don’t have anything to do with those people. I know my agency is handling it, but I don’t know anything about it. I just talked to my family and told them there’s nothing to worry about. I’m just doing my job and trying to get ready for Spring Training and the season. What can I say? It surprised me, too.
“For me, I just want to focus on baseball, be here and pay attention to my team and be ready,” he said. “I know I didn’t do anything wrong.”
Focusing on the game is exactly what Montero has been doing. In today’s game against the San Francisco Giants, Montero showed up by hitting a double and making it home of Alex Liddi’s pop fly ball. In Sunday’s game against the San Diego Padres, Montero showed his stuff by hitting a double and making it home.
Montero began his career in the New York Yankees’ organization, spending the 2008-2011 seasons with the East Coast team. His 2012 average in spring training for the Mariners was .326, and his career average is .348. Thus far in spring training, Montero’s had a .455 average and a .500 OPB. In the regular season, Montero has been batting at .267.
So long as the rumors connecting him to the PED clinic pan out to be false, Montero won’t be going anywhere. He’s a strong batter, and he knows how to make it home. He’s also the guy who gets in front of the ball and he has a .979 spring training career fielding percentage and a .993 regular season percentage. He’s definitely a solid player for the team.

Feb 19, 2013; Peoria, AZ, USA; Seattle Mariners catcher Kelly Shoppach (7) poses for a picture during the Mariners photo day at Peoria Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rick Scuteri-USA TODAY Sports
#7 Kelly Shoppach
Shoppach’s relationship with the Major League dates back to 2006 when he played for the Cleveland Indians. Since then, he’s also played for the Tampa Bay Rays and the Boston Red Sox. Shoppach was recently acquired in a free agent deal replaces Shawn Kelley on the team (he’s since been sent to play for the Yankees).
So far, Shoppach has averaged .600 in spring training. His career spring training average sits at .263, with a season low of .179 in Cleveland and a season high of .361 in Tampa Bay. In the regular season, Shoppach’s average drops – to a career batting average of .226. His OBP for last year was .309.
In Saturday’s game against the Padres, Shoppach made contact with the ball once and struck out once at his two at bats. In Tuesday’s game against the Milwaukee Brewers, Shoppach made it on base twice and was left on base once. He made two doubles during this game.
While it’s still too early to tell how Shoppach will pan out in the long run, thus far, he’s definitely been awake during his times at bat. When it comes to fielding, he has a .989 fielding percentage in spring training games and a .990 fielding percentage in the regular season. Thus far in training, he’s got a 1.000 fielding percentage.
It’s unlikely that these two guys will be shaken up too much on the roster following spring training – so long as they continue to make solid efforts while playing and they stay out of trouble.
What have you thought of their performances in spring training thus far?
Tags: featured, Jesus Montero, Kelly Shoppach, Mariners General, Popular, seattle mariners, spring training
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
Jesus Montero, Seattle Mariners Catcher, Allegedly Linked to Miami PED List

Sep 21, 2012; Seattle, WA, USA; Seattle Mariners designated hitter Jesus Montero (63) waits for the pitch during the game against the Texas Rangers at Safeco Field. Seattle defeated Texas 6-3. Mandatory Credit: Steven Bisig-USA TODAY Sports
According to the New York Daily News Jesus Montero, once a former prospect for the New York Yankees and now a Seattle Mariners catcher, is allegedly on the list of Sam and Seth Levinson clients associated with Anthony Bosch and the latest performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) scandal.
Bosch, who is affiliated with a South Florida clinic that has been linked to the distribution of PEDs to several major league baseball players, also has allegedly supplied New York Yankee bad boy Alex Rodriguez. Now that clinic records are under investigation, several other names have come up, including Montero’s.
The Levinson brothers agent team was already under investigation when Melky Cabrera tested positive for elevated testosterone levels in the summer of 2012. The list also includes Gio Gonzales and Nelson Cruz.
Montero told the Seattle Times that he had no idea why his name came up in the records. He said he’d never even heard of Bosch or his clinic, much less been a client. The Mariners official website gave the following response to the allegations:
The Seattle Mariners strongly support Major League Baseball’s Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program, and are disappointed any time we hear of any players potentially involved with banned substances.
“We are aware of the report which appeared today in The New York Daily News and have been in contact with Major League Baseball to discuss it.
“This matter is now in the hands of the Commissioner’s Office. At this time, with no additional information, we will have no further comment until that investigation has concluded, and all other questions should be directed to Major League Baseball.”
It makes sense that the Mariners’ organization is holding off to comment until they find out whether or not the accusations against Montero have any foundations. Other players named in the New York Daily News article included Milwaukee Brewers outfielder Ryan Braun, Orioles 3rd Baseman Danny Valencia, and Yankees catcher Francisco Cervelli.
Currently, Montero is the only catcher on the Mariners’ 40-man roster, and will be the starting catcher for the Seattle team. He had a .260 batting average last year with 15 home runs and 62 RBIs as he split his time between playing designated hitter and backup catcher. The club has three catchers not currently on the roster: Ronny Paulino, Kelly Shoppach, and Mike Zunino.
So, what do you think about all of this. Is Montero telling the truth? Please answer our poll and post your thoughts in the comments.
Note: There is a poll embedded within this post, please visit the site to participate in this post's poll.
Tags: featured, Jesus Montero, Mariners General, Popular, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
Past, Present, Future – Jesus Montero

Sept 2, 2012; Seattle, WA, USA; Seattle Mariners manager Eric Wedge (right) and catcher Jesus Montero (63) shake hands following a 2-1 victory over the Los Angeles Angels at Safeco Field. Mandatory Credit: Joe Nicholson-US PRESSWIRE
Throughout the coming weeks I am going to go through the Mariner’s players and give a rundown of the player’s past, present, and where I think they are going in the future. I will do the few core players for sure, and may expand it to more of, or the whole roster. While a lot of this is just my opinion, I am going to use statistics to come up with the most accurate projection that I can.
I am going to start with catcher, DH and 1st baseman (?), Jesus Montero.
The Past
Jesus was signed by the Yankees, and worked his way through their minor league system. He was then traded to Seattle along with pitcher Hector Noesi in exchange for rookie phenom Michael Pineda and minor leaguer Jose Campos. We was regarded as one of the top prospects in all of baseball, due to his career 143 wRC+ in the minors.
He played 135 games for the Mariner’s in 2012, and had a slightly disappointing year. He finished with a .295 wOBA and 90 wRC+, along with 15 homeruns. Many people expected him to have a rookie of the year worthy season, but he ended up far from it. He did not show the opposite field power that many were expected, and that may have hurt him in Safeco.
He surprised me a little defensively however. Everyone was talking about how he cannot stay at catcher, and will have to move to 1st or DH. And while that is true, he didn’t look too bad back there to me. I still think he should change positions for the future, but because of the wear and tear that catching brings, and because Mike Zunino figures to take over behind the plate in as little as a year.
Overall, Montero’s season was a little underwhelming. I didn’t expect quite as much as some people did, but I expected more. I thought a .325 wOBA, 110 wRC+ and 22 home runs was very possible, but he came up short.
The Present
I still believe Montero has a bright future, just maybe not as bright as we hoped. This seems to be becoming a pattern with our young players, and hopefully it stops with Montero. He has so much talent, and so many people thought highly of him that it’s hard for me to expect a bust. We have to remember that he is only 22, and it was his first full year.
Another big factor was Safeco, which absolutely killed Montero. His wOBA goes from .328 on the road to .263 at home, and his wRC+ drops from 113 to 68. That is a huge difference, and shows that he is a capable hitter, Safeco just holds him back. I don’t think anyone expected that much of a disparity, since Montero was thought to be a opposite field hitter. We can see here in his hittracker that all but 3 of his homers are to left or left center field. The moving of the fences should help him out a little, and he will continue to improve, but we may still see a different player at home than we do on the road.
The Future
That being said, what do I think of his future?
I expect improvement this year, but not quite as much as we would like to eventually see. I think as high as a .330 wOBA and 115wRC+ with 23-25 HR is in the realm of possibility, but .310/105/20-22 is probably more realistic.
As for the more distant future, I see him making small improvements for the first couple years, then really turning it on at 25-26. I think he will become a perennial .340 wOBA, 125 wRC+, 25 HR guy. Not quite the MVP we hoped for, but a solid player none the less who could find himself in a few All-Star games.
Defensively, I see him moving to DH long term. He may see some first at times too, and could end up playing there full time, but I am still hoping Smoak has finally figured it out and will be our guy there for the future. I don’t think any of us would object to having a DH that can hit like Montero can. I hate making these kinds of comparisons, but I would love having Edgar Jr in the middle of the order for years to come.
Tags: featured, future, Jesus Montero, Mariners General, past, Popular, present, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
The Success of Past Prospects
Ryan Anderson, Ryan Christianson, Chris Snelling, Antonio Perez, Clint Nageotte, Jose Lopez, Travis Blackley, Jeremy Reed, Jeff Clement, Phillippe Aumont, Greg Halman, and Adam Moore. I’m guessing that you have heard some of those names, and I’m guessing you have never heard quite a few of those names. Is this just a random list of players? NO. It’s a list of past Seattle Mariner prospects that made Baseball America’s top 100 Prospect list.
That’s right, these names were once thought to be the future stars of the Mariner organization, yet as we know, none of them really worked out. Sure, Lopez had a few good years before dropping off the face of the earth, and a few other guys have bounced around from team to team and from AAA to the majors for years, but none of them have actually had good major league careers.
As fans, we often look at promising young players and simply expect them to fulfill their potential. I know that I am quite guilty of this. In some of my past articles, I have discussed prospects as if they were sure things, while in reality they are a long ways from being major league caliber players.
In this article, I am going to look at the prospects that we have in our system that have made the 2012 Baseball America top 100 prospects list, and then give a list of past prospects of the same position that have been at similar ranks on past Baseball America lists. This will hopefully put in perspective just how unreliable prospects truly are.
I admit, this is not a perfect analysis of how likely our current prospects are to make the majors, but it will still give a broad comparison to past players that you can use.
The Mariners to make the 2012 list were Jesus Montero (6th), Taijuan Walker (20th), Danny Hultzen (21st), James Paxton (52nd), and Nick Franklin (77th).
Jesus Montero (6th)
We know that Jesus has already made the majors, but that doesn’t mean that he will have long-term success there. Here is a list of catchers who cracked the top 20 from 2010 to 2000.
- Buster Posey (2010, 2009)
- Carlos Santana (2010)
- Matt Wieters (2009, 2008)
- Jarrod Saltalamacchia (2006)
- Joe Mauer (2005, 2004, 2003, 2002)
- Victor Martinez (2003)
As you can see from this list, not many catchers have been ranked in the top 20, but the ones that have made it that high have experienced success. That’s pretty encouraging for the future of Jesus.
Taijuan Walker (20th)
I will include all right-handed prospects that ranked from 15th to 30th.
- Jeremy Hellickson (2010)
- Casey Kelly (2010)
- Kyle Drabek (2010)
- Jacob Turner (2010)
- Rick Porcello (2009, 2008)
- Chris Tillman (2009) Note: The Mariners sent Tillman along with Adam Jones to the Orioles in the Erik Bedard Trade.
- Jerrod Parker (2009)
- Wade Davis (2008)
- Nick Adenhart (2008) Note: Adenhart was tragically killed in a car crash after just four major league appearances.
- Adam Miller (2008, 2007, 2005)
- Yovani Gallardo (2007)
- Mike Pelfrey (2007)
- Matt Garza (2007)
- Bobby Jenks (2006)
- Chad Billingsley (2005)
- Jeff Niemann (2005)
- Jose Capellan (2005)
- Edwin Jackson (2005)
- Dustin McGowan (2004)
- Gavin Floyd (2004)
- Chin-Hui Tsao (2004, 2001)
- Angel Guzman (2004)
- Ervin Santana (2004)
-
Felix Hernandez (2004)
- Jeremy Bonderman (2003)
- Adam Wainwright (2003)
- John VanBenschoten (2003)
- Rafael Soriano (2003, 2002)
- Rich Harden (2003)
- Dennis Tankersley (2002)
- Nick Neugebauer (2002)
- Jerome Williams (2002, 2001)
- Jon Rauch (2002)
- Jake Peavy (2002)
- Boof Bonser (2002)
- Juan Cruz (2001)
- Bobby Bradley (2001)
- Donny Bridges (2001)
- Matt Belisle (2001)
- Kurt Ainsworth (2001)
- Josh Becket (2000)
- A.J. Burnett (2000)
- Brad Penny (2000)
- Tony Armas (2000)
- Ramon Ortiz (2000)
- Francisco Cordero (2000)
This is a very large and diverse list of pitchers. Some of these guys, such as Gallardo, King Felix, and Wainwright are some of the best pitchers in baseball. On the other hand, some of these guys never did anything in a major league uniform. Most of them, however, have had decent major league stints which is encouraging.
Danny Hultzen (21st)
Here are all of the lefty pitchers from 2010 to 2000 that ranged from 15th to 30th on the Baseball America list.
- Martin Perez (2010)
- Aroldis Chapman (2010)
- Tyler Matzek (2010)
-
Brian Matusz (2009)
- Jake McGee (2008)
- Gio Gonzalez (2008)
- Clayton Kershaw (2007)
- Franklin Morales (2007)
- Jon Lester (2006)
- Jeff Francis (2005)
- Mike Hinckley (2005)
- Cole Hamels (2004)
- Sean Burnett (2003)
- Cliff Lee (2003)
- Carlos Hernandez (2002)
- Ty Howington (2002)
- Chris George (2001)
- Matt Riley (2000)
- Wilfredo Rodriguez (2000) Note: Wilfredo may be the coolest name ever.
Wow, that is a very strange list. Nearly all of these guys fall into one of two categories: 1) stud 2) total bust. Honestly though, can anyone say that they have heard a baseball player with a cooler name than Wilfredo? If you have, please put it in the comment section below.
James Paxton (52nd)
All lefty pitchers that have placed between 45th and 60th on the Baseball America lists will be included in this list.
- Casey Crosby (2010)
-
Ross Detwiler (2008)
- Donald Veal (2007)
- Chuck Lofgren (2007)
- John Danks (2007, 2006, 2005)
- Troy Patton (2007)
- Jonathan Sanchez (2007)
- Adam Loewen (2006)
- Jeremy Sowers (2006)
- Scott Elbert (2006)
- Justin Jones (2004)
- Mike Hinckley (2004)
- Andy Sisco (2003)
- Mike Gosling (2003)
- Mario Ramos (2002)
- Jimmy Gobble (2002)
- Mark Phillips (2002)
- Joe Torres (2001)
- Wilfredo Rodriguez (2001)
- Mike Bynum (2001)
- Ed Yarnall (2001)
- C.C. Sabathia (2001)
Well that list of players is downright disturbing, if not devastating. If you can honestly say that you have heard of over half of the names on this list, then I am impressed. Besides Sabathia who has had a great career, John Danks and Jonathan Sanchez who have had their ups and downs, and Wilfredo Rodriguez who has the best name in baseball history, there aren’t many bright spots on that list. This is not to say that James Paxton won’t be a good pitcher, but history certainly doesn’t seem to be in his favor.
Nick Franklin (77th)
I will include both shortstops and second baseman in this list, since it is unclear where Franklin will end up. All prospects that were place from 70th to 85th on past prospect rankings will be included in this list.
- Jiovanni Mier (2010)
- Adrian Cardenas (2009, 2008)
- Reid Brignac (2009)
- Jed Lowrie (2008)
Note: Carlos Triunfel was ranked 89th on the 2009 list and 62nd on the 2008 list.
- Alberto Callaspo (2007, 2004)
Note: Current Pirates second baseman, Neil Walker was placed at 74th on the 2007 rankings, but he was listed as a third baseman. He was also listed as 81st in 2005, but his position was catcher that year.
-
Dustin Pedroia (2006)
- Cliff Pennington (2006)
- Joaquin Arias (2005)
- Brandon Wood (2005)
- Jose Lopez (2004)
- Chase Utley (2003)
- Jake Gautreau (2002)
- Orlando Hudson (2002)
- Luis Montanez (2001)
- Marcus Giles (2000)
- Adam Everett (2000)
Note: Carlos Guillen was ranked 73rd on the 2000 list, but was posted as a 3rd baseman. However, Guillen played every infield position throughout his career.
This list has a couple studs scattered across a sea of busts. A lot of these middle infielders that didn’t work out never really made the majors, but since Franklin is already knocking on the door, that’s seems to bode well for him avoiding the same fate.
Mike Zunino
Mike Zunino was not a Mariner when the 2012 top prospect list was released by Baseball America, but MLB.com released an updated top prospect list in which Zunino ranked 44th. Therefore, I will list past catching prospects that ranked from 35th to 50th on Baseball America lists.
- Derek Norris (2010)
-
Jason Castro (2010)
- Jesus Montero (2009)
- J.P. Arencibia (2009)
- Jeff Clement (2008)
- Geovany Soto (2008)
- Jarrod Saltalamacchia (2007)
- Russell Martin (2006)
- Neil Walker (2006)
- Brian McCann (2005)
- Dioner Navarro (2004)
- Guillermo Quiroz (2004) Note: Quiroz was in the Mariner organization, but not on the 40-man roster, until being traded for cash in September.
- Jeff Mathis (2003)
- Josh Phelps (2002)
- J.R. House (2002)
- Joe Buck (2002)
- Ben Patrick (2000)
- Matt LeCroy (2000)
- Jayson Werth (2000) Note: This IS the same Jayson Werth that is now a star outfielder for the Nationals.
- Steve Lomasney (2000)
The recent prospect to made this list have experienced quite a bit of success while the members of older lists struggled more. Hopefully this trend will benefit Zunino.
My purpose for this article was not to discourage your hope in our future, but to simply give some perspective of just how unpredictable these young prospects can be. As fans, we need to make sure we aren’t counting our eggs before they hatch and basing our future on kids that may or may not work out.
Tags: Danny Hultzen, featured, james paxton, Jesus Montero, Mariners General, Mike Zunino, nick franklin, Popular, Prospect Reports, prospects, seattle mariners, taijuan walker
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
Ending the Season with Colors
We looked on this season as Michael Saunders figured out how to be a valuable major league player; how Franklin Gutierrez continued to suffer from improbable setbacks, yet still produce a respectable line; and how Jesus Montero struggled to perform up to our expectations, among many other things that happened on the diamond. But how do we know what was real and what was flukey? Though sometimes it seems so long, a season is actually pretty short from a statistics perspective. I created the color charts this year—which attempt to show the levels of improvement and above-averageness—in order to help distinguish between significant observations and ho-hum observations.
These are the final two color charts for the 2012 season. First, the comparison to a player’s past performance. Remember that this chart compares a player’s stats from 2012 to his stats from as far back as 2009. The greener the box, the greater the improvement—or in the case of batted balls, the more often the outcome.
It’s important to note that some of these players, like John Jaso and Jesus Montero, didn’t have to play very many games in SafeCo in past years. Even guys like Dustin Ackley, Justin Smoak and Saunders experienced what was deemed an even-more-difficult SafeCo Field this season. So when we look at Saunders’ large improvement in his power numbers—homeruns per outfield flyball (HR/FB) and ISO power—we should consider that improvement as an even more significant jump in talent that has a better chance of sticking next season.
I spoke not-too-kindly of Saunders earlier this season, arguing that he hadn’t shown anything of value to that point. He obviously read my post, and vowed to prove me wrong. In the above chart, Saunders’ row is almost entirely green, now. In fact, the only negative regression came in his outfield flyball rate. But really he just replaced flyballs with line drives and ground balls. For Saunders, this is probably a tradeoff that needed to happen, as we saw his BABIP climb from .262 to .297 this season. With his seemingly sustainable BABIP spike, in combination with a drop in strikeout rate (not shown in chart), his batting average came up from .196 to .247. It wouldn’t hurt if Saunders continued to get better, but his .247/.306/.432 slash line in 2012 was good enough for a guy with an above-average glove in center who also takes half his cuts in SafeCo field.
Saunders’ center field buddy, Franklin Gutierrez, has produced a solid BABIP the last three seasons, so his tradeoff of more outfield flyballs for less grounders was probably healthy. In fact, he pretty much just brought his flyball rates up to meet those of Saunders, and both those guys ended up with similar batted ball profiles, and almost exactly the same BABIP (.297 and .302). So while their changes were opposites, both players produced the changes needed to improve.
What we also saw from Gutierrez was mild improvement (light green color) in both his power numbers and his line drive rate. Though light green represents the least significant of improvements, it does represent some improvement. A guy still suffering from the effects of IBS and/or baseballs in his ear could probably not have exhibited any improvement, and that should be encouragement enough.
But there is no need for me to go through every player. The colors are a helpful way to quickly identify levels of improvement or decline for yourself! On to the league comparison chart, where I have used the colors to indicate a player’s performance relative to the rest of the league.
The player I wanted to point out here is Jesus Montero. His season has definitely been disappointing compared to expectations, and his inability to hit right handers is cause for concern. However, he only struck out 17% of the time (not shown), which is league average, and his HR/FB and ISO were very close to league-average. For a right-handed rookie hitting in SafeCo, league-average power is actually impressive. But the best thing we saw from Montero is probably his 24.6% line drive rate, quite a bit better than league average (moderately green box). SafeCo Field’s marine air shouldn’t do much to affect a player’s contact ability, and Montero posted nearly-identical line drive rates both home and away. But a BABIP gap of 54 points dragged his home numbers down, and with them his overall numbers. On the road, Montero posted a .295/.330/.438 slash line, good for a 113 wRC+. The contact skills are there, and they are more than just one shade of green above the league rates.
The Mariners have to deal with some serious issues before they can contend in the AL West, but we did see real improvement in Michael Saunders, we did see Franklin Gutierrez perform admirably despite injuries, and we did see the contact skills promised from Jesus Montero.
Tags: Color charts, featured, franklin gutierrez, Jesus Montero, Mariners General, Michael Saunders, Popular, seattle mariners, sustain
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
Seattle’s Future at First Bast
If you had asked me two years ago, I wouldn’t have hesitated to tell you that Justin Smoak would be the Mariner’s all-star first baseman by 2013. It’s unbelievable how things change, isn’t it?
The man that was supposedly a future all-star first baseman has done absolutely nothing in a Mariner uniform. He even whiffed his way into AAA this year. Smoak’s struggles have created a vacancy at first base as well.
So, who is the first baseman of the future?
Call me crazy, but I think Smoak deserves a little more time. Not much time, but a little. Essentially, I think that he gets Spring Training and a few months of next year to prove that he is a better option than anyone else. There is simply too much potential and too much value in him to give up on him now. Switch hitting first baseman with plus gloves don’t come around very often. Smoak knows that his career is on the line, and he might be able to make a few adjustments and pull a move like Michael Saunders did this spring.
A lot of people, including myself, had given up on Saunders, but he has turned in a solid season. I think that we should give Smoak an opportunity to turn around his career in a similar way.
In all likelihood, Smoak will not figure out how to hit over the course of an offseason which means that it will be time to look for better answers. There are a few options from within the organization including Mike Carp, Alex Liddi, Jesus Montero, Dustin Ackley, Luis Antonio Jimenez, Vinnie Catricala, Rich Poythress, and Taylor Ard.
I’m not sure what we can expect from Carp. Following an impressive 2011 campaign, Carp has hardly produced and has been constantly bogged down by injuries.
Liddi, who is just 24 years old, has flashed power in his stints in Seattll. Through 144 professional at bats, Liddi has 6
homeruns which averages out to a homerun every 24 at bats. That’s not fantastic, but that should give you a 20-25 homerun season with a starting job. Liddi’s real problem is his strikeouts. While his plate selection and ability to make contact have improved with experience, he still has a contact% of 69.2% and K% of 36.8 in limited time with the big club in 2012.
As soon as Mike Zunino is a catcher, there is a decent chance that Jesus Montero will no longer be given catching duties. When this happens, he will have to either move to DH or first base. Montero could be a good fit at first considering that his bat will profile well there.
Dustin Ackley is another potential first baseman who is already in the system. I would prefer to see Ackley at second since his bat doesn’t provide enough pop to be a good offensive first baseman. Nevertheless, he is a solid last resort.
At the ripe age of 30, Luis Antonio Jimenez could also receive consideration for the MLB job. After demolishing AAA pitching this year, he earned a place on the 40-man roster and a September call-up. Sure, his glove isn’t anything to write home about, but his bat speed and natural power is impressive. I believe that his ability to hit for power is similar to that of Carlos Peguero. The difference between the two players is that Jimenez can actually put the ball in play. Jimenez’ 18.1% K% in AAA isn’t great, but it’s acceptable if you can get good power production in return, and his ISO in AAA was not a big step down from Peguero. The 30 year-old also had a higher OBP and wRC+ than the Peguero. Jimenez becoming the first baseman for the Mariners is certainly a long shot, but it’s also an idea to keep in the back of your mind.
At this time last year, I was convinced that Vinnie Catricala would be a starter on the Mariners in 2013 or 2014, but his 2012 campaign in AAA saw his batting average and OBP drop around 120 points and his SLG% nearly get cut in half from his 60 game stint in AA the previous year. Even worse, his wRC+ went from 184 in AA to 65 in AAA. This drop off is certainly discouraging, but he certainly should not be given up on yet. If “Cat the Bat” can create an assemblance to his 2011 minor league season, he will be a legitimate option at first base in Seattle. He could also play at third base, left field, or right field as well. Last spring training, Catricala challenged for a MLB roster spot, so perhaps he will do the same this year.
Rich Poythress and Taylor Ard were both high level draft picks that play first base as well. Both of them are a ways from being major league caliber hitters, but they are still names to remember in the long run.
Seattle could also look outside of the organization for a first baseman. There are several options which have been discussed in several different articles on this blog, but some of those names are Billy Butler, Ike Davis, Nick Swisher, or Justin Morneau. I am not hugely in favor of dumping lots of money or prospects on anyone right now, but Billy Butler and Ike Davis, who are 26 and 25 years old respectively, could be good trade acquisitions for the right price.
As JJ said in this article, he expected that acquireing Butler would take, “LHP James Paxton, OF/3B Vinnie Catricala or SS Brad Miller, and Erasmo Ramirez and/or Stephen Pryor for Butler and a reliever/AAA throw in.” I’m not willing to give up that much, especially since Butler will end up being a DH. If there was a way to avoid trading Paxton, I would be in, but I don’t think that that is possible.
Tags: alex liddi, Billy Butler, featured, Jesus Montero, justin smoak, Luis Antonio Jimenez, Mariners General, Mike Carp, Popular, Prospect Reports, prospects, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
Seattle’s Future at Catcher
The Mariners are officially out of the playoff hunt, so now that I can stop focusing on this year, I am going to start focusing on the future.
Over the next few days and weeks, I am going to take a look at the future of each position for the Mariners. When I use the term “future,” I am searching for a franchise player who will take over the position and stay for some time. To start my series of articles, I will go behind the dish.
The current catchers on roster are Miguel Olivo, John Jaso, and Jesus Montero. Olivo will likely leave Seattle after the season and Jaso and Montero will remain.
Montero has done a better job than I expected him to when the season began, but he still isn’t going to be a catcher in the
long term. His bat, defense, and value all point towards a career at first base or DH.
Jaso has also had a break out year, but I don’t see him being a guy that will be behind the dish 130 games a year for the next decade.
In the minor leagues, the Mariners have guys including
Brandon Bantz, Jesus Sucre, Ralph Henriquez, Jack Marder, John Hicks, Steven Baron, Mike Zunino, Marcus Littlewood, and Tyler Marlette.
Out of these names, the most likely guy to be a big league catcher is certainly the third overall pick in the 2012 draft, Mike Zunino. The Florida product has steamrolled pitching in A- and AA in his first two months of professional baseball. Before being promoted to AA Jackson, Zunino posted a 1.210 OPS in 29 games at A- Everett.
In Jackson, his production has hardly faltered. After 15 games, he boasts a line of .333/.386/.588 and also three homeruns and four doubles. These stats do not include his astounding performance in the AA playoffs. Zunino is certainly the catcher of the future for the Mariners, the question is when he will be ready to start everyday in Seattle.
Considering the rate that Zunino has accelerated through the farm system, I believe that it is realistic to expect to see him in the MLB next year. If he has a great spring training, Zunino could find himself on the opening day roster, although that would be a bit of a stretch. At the latest, Zunino should be a September call-up in 2013.
Assuming that the Florida product is the long-term solution for catcher that Mariners are searching for, the biggest problem is who will fill the catcher role for the Mariners until Zunino gets there. The John Jaso/Jesus Montero combination should do an adequate job of filling this void until Zunino is capable of replacing them.
As for other options in the minor leagues, none of the other names have a ceiling that is even on the same level as Zunino. Although not quite the same as Zunino, Jack Marder is another good catching prospect the organization. In High Desert this year, he hit .360 with a 1.008 OPS. High Desert teammate, John Hicks, had 49 extra base hits in 121 games. While it’s true that nearly everyone hits well in the California League, don’t entirely write off their performances. Both of those guys could get a look in the MLB if by some disaster Zunino is hit by a meteor or by a plane and is unable to play.
I would bet on Mike Zunino being Seattle’s everyday catcher for a long time, but keep the other names in mind just in case.
Tags: featured, Jack Marder, Jesus Montero, John Hicks, John Jaso, Mariners General, Mike Zunino, Popular, Prospect Reports, prospects, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
The Second Coming of Jesus Montero
On the night of the Supreme Court homage to Felix Hernandez, the Mariners found themselves a little overbooked. In addition to a Safeco Field-sized King’s Court, they were tasked with hosting Salute to Japanese Baseball Night and their third annual Trading Card Night.
Unless you were one of the 15,000 fans with an accommodating work schedule and a lucky parking spot, you may have missed out on the giveaway. The team tastefully omitted any relevant statistics, sparing fans the ugly sight of Chone Figgins‘ batting line (.189/.264/.283) and Kevin Millwood‘s W-L record (4-11). Instead, the cards limited each player to two notable achievements, hobbies, or peculiarities, not unlike those featured on the Jumbotron during games.
Here were the facts selected for Jesus Montero:
- Jesus entered this season rated as the Mariners No. 1 prospect by Baseball America.
- Jesus’ brother, Jesus Rafael Montero, is a catcher in the St. Louis organization.
Yes, you read that correctly. Famed prospect and current catcher Jesus Montero has a brother, the less fabled catcher also named Jesus Montero.
Sure, it’s not the most significant thing we could say about Montero. You can shelf this tidbit with the knowledge that Jesus’ favorite soup is beef and pollo. Still—even considering that the name ‘Jesus’ is the Venezuelan equivalent of Tom, Dick, or Harry—the resemblance between the brothers piqued my curiosity.
First, “our” Jesus. As you may have gleaned from the Mariners’ in-game player profiling, his full name is Jesus Alejandro Montero. At 22 years old, this marks his first full season in MLB and the sixth year of his professional baseball career. Jesus (or Alejandro, for the purposes of this article) began his minor league service at the ripe age of 17, when he signed with the New York Yankees as an amateur free agent in 2006.
From 2010 – 2012, Baseball America ranked him among their top ten prospects, finishing at No. 6 prior to the 2012 season. Although Montero spent his entire minor league career behind the dish, scouts clung tighter to his batting average (above .280 in each of his five seasons) and power numbers (peak SLG: .583 for the high-A Tampa Yankees).
In the shadow of his brother’s fast track to The Show is Jesus Rafael Montero. A year and a half younger, Rafael measures 5’10″ to Alejandro’s 6’3″, though from their headshots the brothers may as well be twins. A year after Alejandro signed with New York, Rafael was selected as a non-drafted free agent by the St. Louis Cardinals. Four seasons later, he has yet to break into the majors, though his path to pro ball also began at age 17.
While both brothers have made names for themselves behind the plate, Rafael has also logged time as a first baseman (17 appearances), designated hitter (2 appearances), right fielder (one appearance), and reliever (one appearance). According to Scout.com, he was named a New York-Penn League All-Star this month, but rendered ineligible to play with a last-minute trip to the DL. A current Batavia Muckdog, Montero’s value may lie more with his glove than his bat: he’s touting a batting line of .287/.360/.434 through 162 PA, a hair above last season’s .276/.339/.347.
Even with the impending departure of Miguel Olivo, this is anything but a plea for the Mariners to lay claim to another Jesus Montero. By age 21, Alejandro made his MLB debut in Fenway Park and notched 20 H, 8 XBH, and 12 RBI in 18 games with New York. By age 21, Rafael is sidelined in the Cardinals’ farm system, with four rungs of minor league levels left to climb.
Perhaps, given a few years’ time, the Monteros will become the Molinas of MLB. Or, just as likely, Jesus Rafael Montero will be known not for his own accomplishments, but as the counterpart to Seattle’s prized backstop.
Tags: Chone Figgins, Jesus Montero, Jesus Rafael Montero, kevin millwood, Mariners General, miguel olivo, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
2013: Catcher Situation
The Mariners figure to make big changes in 2013 as they attempt to fit themselves into the playoff picture. The 2012 team has a few of the right pieces to carry into next season, but a few tweaks will still be necessary in order to really transform this team into a playoff contender. The organization will undoubtedly make more than a few moves that come straight out of the twilight zone, as fans have become more than accustomed to since the Zduriencik administration has taken over.
Regardless of the moves that will or won’t be made, it’s important to be aware of the fans climate going into the offseason. Fans opinions don’t usually factor into the front office decision making process, however that doesn’t mean there isn’t an interest in the fans opinion. There is no team, no money, no ballpark without the fans. So understanding that your opinion matters, but isn’t critical to the future of the Seattle Mariners organization, here at Sodo Mojo, we have a few polls for you rito peruse.
Dependent on the statistics you value, there aren’t many positions that don’t require an upgrade. Some of those upgrade will come within, and the other will obviously have to come from outside the organization. So without further ado…
Note: There is a poll embedded within this post, please visit the site to participate in this post's poll.
Tags: Jesus Montero, John Jaso, Mariners General, Popular, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
2013: 1st Base Situation
The Mariners figure to make big changes in 2013 as they attempt to fit themselves into the playoff picture. The 2012 team has a few of the right pieces to carry into next season, but a few tweaks will still be necessary in order to really transform this team into a playoff contender. The organization will undoubtedly make more than a few moves that come straight out of the twilight zone, as fans have become more than accustomed to since the Zduriencik administration has taken over.
Regardless of the moves that will or won’t be made, it’s important to be aware of the fans climate going into the offseason. Fans opinions don’t usually factor into the front office decision making process, however that doesn’t mean there isn’t an interest in the fans opinion. There is no team, no money, no ballpark without the fans. So understanding that your opinion matters, but isn’t critical to the future of the Seattle Mariners organization, here at Sodo Mojo, we have a few polls for you rito peruse.
Dependent on the statistics you value, there aren’t many positions that don’t require an upgrade. Some of those upgrade will come within, and the other will obviously have to come from outside the organization. So without further ado…
Note: There is a poll embedded within this post, please visit the site to participate in this post's poll.
Tags: Jesus Montero, justin smoak, Mariners General, Popular, seattle mariners
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »
The First Base Predicament
When the Mariners acquired Justin Smoak as the center piece to the Cliff Lee deal, they believed they were shoring up the not-so-hot-corner for the next decade. Smoak was everything the Mariners could ask for, a switch hitting power hitter who had received zealous comparisons to Mark Texiera. The deal was the right move to make, Smoak was an untouchable prospect on nearly every teams radar. Everyone wanted him.
As things often do in Mariners Universe, it didn’t work out as planned. Smoak has flashed brief stints of the ability and talent that Zduriencik believed he was getting, but when his entire body of work is reviewed as an overall entity, it has been nothing short of an unmitigated disaster. Smoak has been the worst everyday 1st basemen in the league, and it’s not even close. The Mariners didn’t even gamble, and they still lost.
The organization is teetering on the edge of calling it quits with regards to the former gem of the Cliff Lee spoils. His recent demotion to AAA is still being paraded as a temporary*, though his performance hasn’t exactly inspired anyone to believe such a thing. Carp has taken over first base duties in Smoak’s absence, and while his performance has been an upgrade it still isn’t representative of an everyday, productive, Major League first baseman. On top of Carp’s interrupted performance, he has found it extraordinarily difficult to stay off the Disabled List this season. The Mariners haven’t found the answer between Carp and Smoak, and they now have many routes they are going to have to explore.
The options are aplenty, internal and external. We discussed a few external options earlier (Link1, Link2), but for I’ll make it easy for you and re post a couple of them here, with more detail.
Davis brings a bit of a mixed bag to the table. The power is legitimate but, so are his strikeout issues. His struggles this season have stemmed mostly from a low BABIP. Rumors have begun to swirl that the Mets aren’t comfortable moving forward to Davis as their future 1st baseman, making him a prime target for acquisition this offseason. Davis isn’t what most would categorize as a super star, but affordable and above league average, that certainly describes this potential offseason addition.
I wouldn’t say the Royals are actively trying to move Butler, I wouldn’t say they wouldn’t move him either. Butler unlIke Davis is coming at a premium. He is in the midst of a career best season, and his age fits perfectly into the Royals future plans. A few concerns come to mind with Butler as well. One, as mentioned earlier, is cost. He isn’t going to come cheap and the Mariners may have to deal someone they are uncomfortable parting with in order to acquire the Royals first baseman. Second is Butler’s primary hand. Right handed pull hitters don’t fair well in the thick marine air of SafeCo and coming to Seattle would zap a large portion of his power.
Obviously the Mariners will take a look at sure fire studs such as Freddie Freeman, Carlos Santana, or Paul Goldschmidt, but just because you shop for a Lamborghini, doesn’t that you wish to bury yourself in debt in order to own it.
Internal options becomes a bit more complicated. Seattle doesn’t have a complete first base prospect awaiting in the wings at the moment. That was Smoak’s role to fill. However the organization does have a few pieces they can shift around in hopes of creating a permanent option.
Many forget that when Ackley was originally drafted he was playing 1st base for his college squad. He started out his collegiate career as a center fielder, but finished it at 1st due to Tommy John Surgery. We’ve seen Dustin man the position a few times this season and it hasn’t been a complete disaster, but he doesn’t exactly fit the mold of what you are looking for in the position either. Ackley is a temporary fix at best, and eventually the Mariners would have to find someone else to play the position. I do believe however that Ackley fits the CF mold perfectly… but that is a whole post in itself.
The Mariners pretty much explained to the world that Jesus Montero was not the catcher of the future when they drafted Mike Zunino. I’m not suggesting that they drafted from a position of need, but I am saying that if they wanted a pitcher instead, they could have had one. Montero has been taking ground balls at first all season long, and while the manager insist he isn’t ready, he is going to have to get into the field eventually. When the games don’t matter… I can’t picture a better time. Montero isn’t left handed, which puts him at a minor disadvantage, but I see no reason why he can’t play there and be at the very least average.
He recent stretch of injuries may have bought him one more season of auditions. Carp’s 2011 still has many hooked and interested. Carp certainly isn’t the worst option in the world, but a return to near 2011 form would be necessary in order to justify putting him in the lineup day in and day out. His 2012 has been near impossible to evaluate, which may buy him a shot in 2o13.
Of course you still have Smoak who is still technically an option, but I’m doubtful the Mariners are going to stand pat at 1st this offseason and allow Smoak to be the teams “best” option over there at first. Then again the organization has had a hard time admitting bust, just look at Chone Figgins who is still here, so Smoak may still have a lengthy leash. 1st base is now a bit of an enigma and one that the Mariners puzzle solvers are going to have to figure out. The winter meetings ought to be fun this year.
* The Mariners have recalled Smoak placing Carp on the DL with strained left groin
Tags: Billy Butler, featured, Freddie Freeman, Ike Davis, Jesus Montero, justin smoak, Mariners General, Popular
Posted in: Mariners | No Comments »












